
October 5, 2009
Third Meditation on Pittsburgh G-20
We face a wall of riot police, standing there in the street. Of course, they create the absence of a safe passage through their wall. We can’t march that way. There is no soft door in their ranks. None of these folks want to talk, and as we try to engage their eyes somewhere deep in their Darth Vader helmets, we don’t know where their eyes are focusing. Meanwhile, as they slap their hands with their clubs, they accuse us of violence while we shout about Peace.
They are in the foreground but at the same time they are in the distance, as vast as a landscape. Their body armor has the repeating edges and shapes, the lines from body to body that dominate the visual – like the façade of an office building. We forget about the bodies underneath and see the structural overlay. These repeating lines give off the same inscrutability as a suburban Wal Mart. Oh yes, this is very familiar. We Americans know the forced absence of meaning in the enclosures of social control. We silently rope-a-dope with the mono-culture throughout our day.
In the USA, our “Sea of Identical Details,” is so dully omnipresent that some of us will go into a chain store like Starbucks and put our hands on the cash register and shout to God – just to have a feeling, any feeling at all. We put our hands on the the genitals of the corporation to incite a response, to make someone come running who is honestly confused, slipping out of their military self-possession. Oh what a relief that someone would shout, “What are you DOING?” The American built environment is so bullying that ordinary people must do extraordinary things, and some of us volunteer for war, or for turning into a human wall, or any number of habitual altered states. Some part of us, though, feel a silent terror that we are lending our lives to sentimental patriotism, the most deadly form of Consumerism.
We watch our taxes finance 2 inch wide clouds of yellow pixels on the television screen. Body parts fly around the screen like litter in the wind. Then we watch our children sneak off to point the cursors that fly those same predator drones over imagined villages. We stare at our bizarre native land and we try to figure it out. On the one hand we have these huge expressionless crowds of isolated people, and then we have these screaming sports crowds, and then we have bloodied bodies on the front page. We would like a few minutes to ask if this is the way things should be. But there is no time for waiting. We are distracted by this entertaining wall, a screen that has a secret deal with our optic nerves…
Maybe these young people staring at us from inside those helmets have got the right view of preposterous America. What other world have they entered by standing there and imitating a wall? Maybe the people inside this wall are actually unaffected and kind. When they step out of the metallic vests and straps, back in their locker-room somewhere, are they laughing and ribbing each other, just a part of a tribe, doing a job? So today they contained some peace marchers. Are we all supposed to be in those uniforms? Is that the final march to Consumerism?
They are in the foreground but at the same time they are in the distance, as vast as a landscape. Their body armor has the repeating edges and shapes, the lines from body to body that dominate the visual – like the façade of an office building. We forget about the bodies underneath and see the structural overlay. These repeating lines give off the same inscrutability as a suburban Wal Mart. Oh yes, this is very familiar. We Americans know the forced absence of meaning in the enclosures of social control. We silently rope-a-dope with the mono-culture throughout our day.
In the USA, our “Sea of Identical Details,” is so dully omnipresent that some of us will go into a chain store like Starbucks and put our hands on the cash register and shout to God – just to have a feeling, any feeling at all. We put our hands on the the genitals of the corporation to incite a response, to make someone come running who is honestly confused, slipping out of their military self-possession. Oh what a relief that someone would shout, “What are you DOING?” The American built environment is so bullying that ordinary people must do extraordinary things, and some of us volunteer for war, or for turning into a human wall, or any number of habitual altered states. Some part of us, though, feel a silent terror that we are lending our lives to sentimental patriotism, the most deadly form of Consumerism.
We watch our taxes finance 2 inch wide clouds of yellow pixels on the television screen. Body parts fly around the screen like litter in the wind. Then we watch our children sneak off to point the cursors that fly those same predator drones over imagined villages. We stare at our bizarre native land and we try to figure it out. On the one hand we have these huge expressionless crowds of isolated people, and then we have these screaming sports crowds, and then we have bloodied bodies on the front page. We would like a few minutes to ask if this is the way things should be. But there is no time for waiting. We are distracted by this entertaining wall, a screen that has a secret deal with our optic nerves…
Maybe these young people staring at us from inside those helmets have got the right view of preposterous America. What other world have they entered by standing there and imitating a wall? Maybe the people inside this wall are actually unaffected and kind. When they step out of the metallic vests and straps, back in their locker-room somewhere, are they laughing and ribbing each other, just a part of a tribe, doing a job? So today they contained some peace marchers. Are we all supposed to be in those uniforms? Is that the final march to Consumerism?

Comments
darth vader robocop
the first time i heard you talk about the darth-vader-robocop types you encountered during the G-20 was at brennan & catherine's home...i feel like i've been seeing them everywhere on different levels. i was in maine recently and at the single-gate terminal in bar harbor my two 10 oz jams were "voluntarily confiscated" because they were technically liquid. the people who rummaged through my luggage and told me to also select one container from my toiletries to give up, they were...well they seemed like “good people.” i'm sure they have families and their favorite things to do on the weekend and all the other things that make us human. but they just followed these arbitrary rules regarding security...in my office yesterday we were going over marketing and the mailings that people would receive…we were all baffled by the manipulative tactics that were going into place to receive donations and all we did was shake our heads and make jokes shocked at the latest techniques to buy that charitable happiness. at some point we/i all need to really tear ourselves from this reality. speak up, stand out…something. i think we are…but we have this warped shifted sense of ourselves and even when we question the american corporation we do so out of the sides of our mouths while our hands and arms are busy buying and covering our eyes. maybe that’s what is happening with these robocops? but there is hope…i know we have hope…but that faith in something better can’t act as rigid blinders forever.
xox
Consumerism Is A Matter Of Proximity To Violence
You're right, we're all "nice people, doing what we can" and we are distanced from the violence of our actions based on our status, with the occaisional extreme close-up erupting from the horizon.
We break out of the violence when break out of the purchase! But it's tough work...it takes time!
I really thank to one who
I think people must first research before writing...
Brothers don't shoot
We add to Dr King’s four fronts a fifth front, the pocket book. The phrase voting with their pocket book hints at the power of this front. The G 20 is all about business. Perhaps our greatest power lies in how we spend our money. Buying fair trade, keeping our money in the local economy, not supporting sweatshops and slavery and showing shop owners the benefits so they say to the producer, my customers won’t buy products whose production pollutes, my customers won’t buy products made by slaves and my customers want to buy products made by local industry.
It has been suggested that to change the world we must begin with ourselves. If we begin, our example influences others and we will change the world.
AMEN!
So sad, so moving, so scary
Maybe it's the waxing moon and all the decomposing and deconstruction that can accompany it...but your message hit hard.
Who are these faceless armored youth willing to drop their joysticks for a dayjob of tear gas and bullying? Or are they middle aged, counting out their 20 year pension, looking for something closer to street duty but further from desk duty with NO RISK.
notice: "These crowds will not be armed and dangerous. They will be carrying signs, hopes, tears and good wishes for a better future for all of mankind. These crowds are peaceful and harmless. A Little loud and boisterous. and you have our permission (tax paid and enforced) to treat them as your robocop darth vader line of white and silver see fit. The crowd has no recourse. You have all power. Do as you are commanded. AND NO ONE WILL EVER SEE YOUR FACE "
I don;t know, but sounds a lot like terroristic techniques to me. I am not looking to blur the line and call them terrorists (that's sloppy thinking and trust me the other side is very willing to slop EVERYTHING UP and they are better at is, so we can;t win a descent into baser nature nastiness)
Please robo boys. Call your mother and ask her if it's ok to hurt, bully and capture sign holding, peace chanting, hopeful thinking cousins, neighbors, strangers, brothers and sisters.
Post new comment